🔍 Solve the Mystery—Win a Cup of Coffee

🔍 Solve the Mystery—Win a Cup of Coffee

☕ Chapter One: The Routine That Was Broken

The Stirred Spirits CafĂ© isn’t haunted, exactly—just aware.
The floorboards creak only under certain people.
The steamer hisses when someone lies.
And the tip jar fills more on days the moon is waning.

Milo was part of that rhythm. He always wore a watch, always carried a leather journal, and always tipped exactly 15%—no more, no less.

So when barista Devyn saw him standing in line holding cash, she felt it in her molars.

“Something’s off,” she told her coworker.
“Maybe he’s just switching it up?”
“He doesn’t believe in milk.”

đŸ§Ÿ Chapter Two: The Order That Wasn’t Milo’s

There’s a receipt. Timestamped: 7:32 a.m.
Item: Chai Latte, Oat Milk, Extra Hot
Name: Milo G.
Paid: Cash
Barista: Devyn

But the security footage shows the drink being made
 at 7:48 a.m.

And Milo?
He’s there at 7:32—on camera. Wearing the same green coat. Holding no cash. Never speaking.

At 7:35, the camera glitches—static, then a flicker.
When the feed returns
 he’s gone.
The drink is still being made.
But the person picking it up? Hood up, face down, not Milo.

🧂 Chapter Three: The Milk Frother Whispered

Here’s where it gets weird. Devyn swears she heard the milk frother say something.

“Whhhoooorrrreee
”

“What?”

“Nothing,” said the frother. Loudly.

That machine never worked right, but this was
 personal.

Devyn replayed the sound later. It wasn’t an insult. It was a name.

“Rory.”
Rory Holloway—Milo’s estranged nephew, who had disappeared for five years before resurfacing two towns over.

And he drinks chai lattes. Oat milk. Extra hot. Always.

🔍 Chapter Four: The Conspiracy Begins to Perk

A few things start dripping out:

  • Milo had rewritten his will the day before the disappearance.

  • Rory had been spotted outside the cafĂ© twice that week, wearing a green coat—identical to Milo’s.

  • A second receipt is found in the trash, timestamped 7:48, with the same order—but this time the name is “R. Holloway.”

  • The cash? Marked as part of a missing envelope from the library’s donation box.

Milo’s house?
Locked from the inside.
Journal left open to a page that just said:

“He doesn’t even LIKE cinnamon.”

đŸ‘» Chapter Five: Not Quite Alone

Devyn returns to the café after hours, unable to let it go. She pulls one last shot of espresso and stares at the steam curling from the mug.

The lights flicker.

The milk frother lets out one long hiss.
In it, faintly:

“Not him. Not me. Not yet.”

🧠 The Clues for You:

  • Why was Milo’s usual routine broken that day?

  • Who paid in cash—and why is that the only time he ever did?

  • What was Rory’s motive?

  • Why does the frother keep talking—and why did Milo’s watch stop at 7:33 a.m. on the dot?

đŸ—‚ïž Your Turn: Solve It

Submit your theory in the comments or email us at unlawfulthreads@gmail.com.
The closest guess will win a mystery mug and possibly a cursed milk steamer.

Back to blog

Leave a comment